Clear Cut Liquid Eyeliner - Flüssig-Eyeliner

The worst eyeliner ever.

Absolutely terrible. It was dry immediately within first use. Such a bummer. It’s so bad. Literally unusable.

Does not have staying power

Pro: does not run. Con: does not have staying power. Half of the eyeliner closer to the eyeline is gone after 4-5 hours of wear. It just fades. I would only wear it if I don’t need makeup on for more than 3 hours. Don’t waste your money.

AWFUL - BARELY WORKS

Straight out of the packet the eyeliner was dry and cakey. Haven't been able to do a nice line at all. Don't buy ☹️

What the Gaga?

I read the reviews. I thought surely no eyeliner can be that bad. I've had cheap eyeliner and Gaga wouldn't sell us junk, would she? Believe the reviews. To add salt to the eye corners, the first time I used it it was blacker than black and the brush tip...so tiny, such precision...I have finally located the one for the difficult to line wrinkles of my 57 year old skin! I carefully put the cap on securely and tucked it into my eyeliner jar upside down to keep the tip from drying out. Next morning, shook, took cap off, and began to carefully line my eye...it skipped across my eyelid but I loyally thought it my error...but no...it was truly just garbage. What skipped on, flaked off shortly thereafter and not too long after that, the black turned into a griity watercolor substance that irritated the corners of my eyes and turned them into raw meat. It's a one use wonder. We feel betrayed by you Gaga...will you make it right or are you just going to enjoy our hard earned money? Your loyal fans await, with raw, unlined, tear stained eyes. Really though, I feel betrayed by another greedy celebrity make up company. Gaga can keep her poker face.

Allergic reaction

Similar to another user - I had a terrible allergic reaction. Not sure what is in the ingredients that would have caused it. I’m allergic to pineapple and other tropical fruits which maybe part of the “herbal” ingredients.

Dislike!

I purchased this because I loved the advertisements with Lady Gaga. Silly me. It's awful. Smudges, fades and what does stay in the am wears off by mid afternoon. Would not purchase again.

Perfect Liquid Matte

I love this eyeliner. I usually prefer a felt tip but the fiber tips are really smooth and easy to manipulate for different size wings. It’s so matte without being flaky and looks flat to the skin instead of raised like thicker products. It doesn’t bleed after a long day and even survived me crying and wiping my eyes at the movies. I’ve waited a year to post a review because liquid eyeliner is probably my number one used beauty product to make sure I actually like it and it has yet to let me down. I will definitely be rebuying this.

Allergic Reaction

Unfortunately this product really irritated my eyes and gave me really bad allergies. I’m not sure what ingredients in this item would have caused that because it’s supposed to be a clean product.

Dry and thin

It’s not that great the felt tip has bent at the tip a little and only small amounts come out before thinning out. I layer it with the elf eyeliner because it’s not black enough. Especially for the price I’d expect better. Her foundation is top tier.

Could have been nice, I looked for an eyeliner with clean ingredients. But this was like putting money into the trash, it dried out after 2 days.

Excellent liquid eyeliner

I have used this eyeliner for a couple of months and love the long staying power.

Waste of money.

Not waterproof at all. The worst Liquid eyeliner I have ever used. Waste of money.