Colorgraph Crayon - Eyeliner

Didn't smudge all day!

I absolutely love the Valentino Colorgrah Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil! The texture is creamy and glides on effortlessly without tugging at my skin. The shade Brown Fondant is the perfect deep navy shimmer — it gives my eyes definition while still adding a fun pop of color. I wore it all day and it didn’t smudge or transfer, even through humidity. The built-in brush is a great bonus for blending out the liner into a softer, smoky look. I’ve tried many eyeliners, but this one feels luxe and stays put like no other. Highly recommend if you want something long-lasting and bold!

NOT a waterproof

It is NOT a waterproof pencil as marketed. It fades in a couple of hours. I had higher expectations considering price and brand.

This IS IT for your waterline. Run don't walk!

This stuff does NOT transfer out of your waterline at all. I have tried about 20 liners that were all highly rated for the waterline and all failed. This one IS A WINNER!!! FINALLY I can tightline without it transferring all over the lower waterline. The price is my only complaint but the product is 10 out of 5! Get it!

I received this product in exchange for my honest review. The eyeliner is perfect for blue eyes , anytime I wear it out I get the most compliments that it thst does bring out my eyes. Highly recommend buying this , it also glides perfectly . I actually repurchased another one with my own money .

Nope

So I bought two, one in the brown fondant and the black. I can't tell you about the wear because it immediately started burning my eyes. Like uncomfortable enough that I immediately cleaned it off. The black, after I decided to try it, was good..so I think maybe it's just this one or this color. The black is fire though. I definitely returned this. On to the next!

Great and long lasting

Gliding smoothly and long lasting. I was afraid it won’t be the same once it’s sharpened but all good. I used Sephora sharpener and it looks okay after. I also purchased in brown after I liked the black one.

Perfect

If you like the eyeliner pencils from VB, you’ll adore these too!! I love the jewel tones

Lovely subtle colour and soft

Very subtle shade but soft eye pencil , easy to use

Beautiful color

This product is very pigmented you literally need two swipes and you get a beautiful finish. I love the shimmer it isn’t super noticeable but barely there. The brush side is super helpful to smear the product out. This product also doesn’t smear and you have to use an oil to remove it.

Best brown sparkly eyeliner … and I’ve tried a lot

I received the Valentino Color Graph Waterproof Gel Liner in Brown Fondants as a free product, and I am absolutely in love! It’s the best brown liner I’ve ever used, with the most stunning glitter that adds a subtle yet luxurious sparkle to any look. The formula glides on effortlessly, stays put all day, and truly lives up to its waterproof claims. While it’s on the pricier side, it’s 100% worth the investment, and I will absolutely repurchase it once I run out.

Beautiful pigment!

I love this eyeliner! The color is so pretty - like a slightly metallic brown. The application was great and it went on so smoothly with no smudging. It was great for lining my upper lid and I especially loved it in my waterline. Definitely recommend!

Love this eyeliner!

I love this eyeliner! It is the perfect neutral brown shade with a little shimmer. Goes on smoothly and blends out so nicely with the included blending brush. Has great pigmentation and stay power! I have watery eyes from wearing contacts and I did not have any smudging or running. Will definitely be using this as my go-to eyeliner!