Always Sharp Wasserfester Kohl-Eyeliner

Perfect eye tight-liner

The perfect eyeliner for tight-lining my upper lashes! It stays put all day making my eyes naturally pop. Downside is a design flaw when sharpening, causing the tip to break off sometimes.

My favorite eyeliner

This is such an underrated eyeliner. I've been using these for years because it's so convenient twist up and last all day. Does not smudge and are pigmented.

Breaks

Really dislike this eyeliner. It has broken about 3 times since purchasing this a week ago. It self sharpens so you can’t twist it back in to prevent it from breaking. Would not recommend or purchase again.

Not what I expected

Not what I expected but so far it’s okay, at the beginning I don’t know how to use it but accidentally I click the cap and it sharpen the pencil, so easy but I guess the prove is kind of high compare any other.

Doesn’t last

The first time I bought this eyeliner I loved it. Since I’ve restocked twice and it doesn’t last. Not sure if it’s breaking inside but it barely lasted a month. Now going back to my previous brand

Self sharpening lid-the BEST!

I have been using this and the brown for years. Glids on so easily. You don't twist you have to pump up. Never had any problems with braking in lid, just keep it low and sharpened bc it's softer is all. LOVE the self sharpening lid!

Not happy with how it goes on. Flaky and messy when applying it.

The best eyeliner ever

I can't give this higher stars. It's perfect. Perfect color pay off, perfect consistency, excellent in the water line, and always sharp. I've tried them all; fenty, sephora, marc jacobs, tarte, urban decay but I always keep coming back to this one. I wish it had more colors but other than that it's perfection.

Save your money and buy a drugstore eyeliner. It goes on beautiful, no complaints there. But there is nothing waterproof about this. It wears off, smudges off, rubs off very easily. I spent all that extra money because it said it was waterproof but they lied. If you’re looking for a nice eyeliner that goes on easy this is definitely OK, but if you’re looking for something that is waterproof and going to last more than an hour or two then this is not for you.

This is the second time this has happened, but after the second or third time maybe using the pencil, the top of the liner fell off and became unusable. A complete waste.

Its a no!

Always loved this Smash Box eye liner as it is always sharp but, I now find that it runs if your eyes start tearing when applying. I would not recommend this longer, not as great as it once was. No longer waterproof!

While this applies well and smooth, it smudges way too easily where I find it under my eye and on my eyelid throughout the day.