12H Intense Ink Felt Liner Classic Line - Präziser Intensiver Filzstift-Eyeliner

Dries out quickly

I loved this for the first week I used it, then it just dried out! It was a great color of brown, I am really bummed it didn't last long.

A must have in my routine💕

Out of all the eyeliners I’ve tried, this one is my absolute favorite. The pigment is intense, the shade lasts all day, and it makes my eyes look flawless. I’ve gotten so many compliments — and yes, it’s waterproof too!

The worst

This is a terrible replacement for the wink-it eye liner. It runs, it smudges, it seeps into cracks. Literally the worst. Don’t buy this.

Bring the old formula back

Please bring the old formula back I used it for years I don’t like the new one at all

I was struggling to find a new eyeliner that stayed on all day and didn’t wipe off easily - this is the product. Also, I am always hesitant on waterproof but this came off easy. Would recommend.

Don't recommend

Returned I loved this at first and after only a couple wears it was drying out. When I'd draw a line the liquid would run out and draw a partial dry line so I would try to go back over the line and it was just so dry it would just pull the color off.

Bring back Wink-It

I normally don't write reviews, but I was so sad to see that the Wink-It Felt Liner was discontinued. Echoing everyone to bring it back. I bought this to try out as a replacement and it doesn't compare. The richness of the black is great, but it's not waterproof at all. Any slight liquid, sweat or water causes it to smudge. Even though it wasn't fool-proof the Wink-It at least had a higher tolerance against smudging. This is a poor substitute.

A bone is probably less dry that this

First day - brilliant pigmentation, 2nd day - 10% pigmentation - now its bone dry. I was super disappointed

Ink skipped from the second i bought it and it completely dried in a few months. I didn’t even use it daily! i’m never against store brands this one was a no for me

Must have!

Such a good eyeliner. It is predictable and reliable. Will always reach for this over others when given the opportunity!

Great product!

Great eyeliner; great precision on lash line! I love my chocolate brown choice as I now find black too intense on my aging eyes!

literally awful

used this product only a few times and it was so bad. It says waterproof but after 2 seconds it will be running and smudging across your entire face-not just your eyes. i do not recommend.