Better Than Sex - Waterproof Eyeliner

Not the best wear, finicky applicator.

If this product weren’t labeled “waterproof” I’d say the formula is fine, but after a few hours of wear it does transfer to my lids a bit and I don’t have oily lids or wear cream shadow. My main issue is with the applicator, or overall product design I guess. Despite recapping it securely and immediately following use, and storing it applicator down, it seems to dry out and kind of gum up and therefore clog and every other day I have to run it under extremely hot water to clean it and get it going again. Wastes product and kind of a hassle.

I will pretty much always repurchase

FAV! One stick lasts me a good 6 months, usually longer. I’ve been using it since high school. It lasts all day, my wings are often perfect, but it’s really expensive which is off putting. It’s amazing though. I’d definitely recommend.

Not as good as the black one

I really wanted to love this one as much as I love the black one. Unfortunately it is not a long lasting wear, I find that it desolves of my eyelids in a couple of hours. Also pigment is not as strong as for the black one.

Love it!

It looks more natural than black and durability is awesome.

No!

Bought this color twice hoping to getter a better product and both times returned it , not comparable with the black color -that gave 5 star to. something is off about the pigments and applicator.

the pigment is so bad and not visible after aplyig

Smudges and moves

Tried it unfortunately it smeared on my eye lids. If you have oily skin, this will not work for you.

Best eyeliner ever. Made my brown eyes pop, and very easy to apply. Doesn’t not smudge.

Has gone down hill

I used to love this product. However recently I noticed it runs out very quickly and doesn’t apply as nicely as it used to. It comes out as very thin and see through. I would not recommend spending the money.

Garbage

Garbage, not worth the money. The tip doesn’t last even past first use.. if even.

Used to be great

This eyeliner used to be my go-to. But the last couple of times I've bought it, the quality has decreased... can be leaky, the tip can easily fray... I'm looking for a new brand this time.

Not like previous eyeliner

Seems like the applicator is make of wire. Doesn’t put much product down while scratching my eye.