Fullest Volumizing - Mascara

Staying power: 0/10

First, the wand/brush is awkward for my hooded eyes. Not only was I unable to apply the product without getting it on my lids, I found it difficult to maneuver the wand to the base of my lashes to give them the lift I was seeking. Second, this product does not stay put for me, even with setting powder. Within 3-4 hours it migrated to below my eyes and was difficult to remove without removing my foundation and concealer, too. Lastly, this mascara gave me a headache every time I used it. My eyes are very sensitive to eye shadows and mascaras. I thought that “Clean Beauty” meant I would not have a reaction to it; however, I noticed that within an hour of applying it, I started getting a headache.

Could be better but not awful

Definitely is lengthening and provides good volume. It does smudge which I don’t love. I’m trying to find the perfect clean mascara. This is getting closer but is not perfect.

I would not buy

I used to use Tarte's Lights Camera Lashes for forever. It was my HG but they changed the formula which changed its performance. So I'd been shopping around and was using this mascara for a while before realizing it was responsible for ruining my lashes. It says it's not waterproof but it's a struggle bus to get it off, even with makeup removing liquids and balms. It made me lose eyelashes and prevented them from growing back. Once I switched to another mascara, Diorshow, my lashes grew back, and stopped shedding. Just my own experience but I would not recommend this.

love, super natural looking but really lengthening

Love! Long natural lash game strong.

I received a mini version as part of a holiday mini mascara set with a coupon for a full size. This was by far my favourite. Natural long lashes, say no more! I keep reaching for this over my BTS, but love both!

The best!!

This is the best mascara I’ve ever tried! It doesn’t clump, it makes my eyelashes super long and it doesn’t smudge! I’m so happy that I’ve finally found a mascara that WORKS!

Not great.

I originally got the mascara in the white tube and loved it. This one I found very clumpy and just over all unflattering. I didn’t like it at all. The only reason I didn’t return it was because I had just taken off my lash extensions and thought it would get better.

Not worth it

Burns the eyes, smells strong and doesn't last. Wears off after a few hours

Not long lasting

This wear off really poorly. I love the look and formula but it doesnt wear well and leave raccoon eyes

Disappointing!

I want to preface that I bought this because of the great reviews! This is the worst mascara I’ve tried. It’s a very odd formula- super wet but also very dry at the same time. Very strange wand. Difficult to use without getting mascara everywhere. I have long eyelashes and it made them spidery, clumpy, and hard. The worst raccoon eyes I’ve ever had. Not even an hour after applying, raccoon eyes. I had to keep wiping it off my bottom eyelid throughout the day. Definitely overrated and just a really bad product.

Raccoon eyes.

Raccoon eyes guaranteed. Loved the wand but not The formula. Easy to take off because it is all Under the eyes. Even with setting Powder would not recommend or ever Purchase again.

So disappointed in the new changes!!

This was my tried and true mascara since it launched, but my most recent repurchase left me so disappointed and confused. Yes the packaging is new, but the bristles alto feel different and the formula is much dryer. Doesn't matter how much product you try to get on the brush it just ends up feeling dry and end up with much less volume than it used to give. It pefect: clean ingredients, excellent volume and wear, lightweight, no smudging or flaking. Why change something that was perfect?? Now I have to hunt for a replacement...