They're Real! Magnet Mascara

Okay

Personally wasn’t very good for me but works great with some of my friends so idk

Smudges and ruins your makeup

Smudges and makes you look like a raccoon drugstore mascara is better than this! Horrible

Not worth it—smudging and lack of length

With Asian lashes and eyes, this mascara did not hold up well, which is why I only got the mini version to test it out. Very noticeable smudging under the eye within 15 minutes of application—I squint when I smile, so it rubbed off on my bottom lid and made me look like a raccoon. Lengthening was subpar and I could find a better, full size, lengthening mascara for the same price as this mini at the drug store. Did not hold the curl very well, ended up being droopy by hour 2. Overall, this mascara kind of sucked. Do not waste your money.

New formula and no longer a good product.

I'm so disappointed. This has been my favourite mascara for years, but I recently bought a new one (Aug 2025) and discovered it's completely different. The formula seems thin and weak now, almost like a two-year-old mascara. It's just crusty and doesn't seem to stick to my lashes at all.

36

Eine stinknormale Mascara, nichts innovatives gemerkt, was in der Beschreibung versprochen wurde. Ziemlich trocken.

Favourite!

Tried this and I love it. It stays on through me sweating all day and looks good. It gives your lashes volume and length. I used to use Smashbox Superfan and switched to this one. After sometime it does thicken in the tube though.

My new obsession

Its quite extraordinary how flawlessly this mascara coats your eyelashes. Incredible links and volume without any of the clumping (which I for one cannot tolerate). Def a game changer. I have yet to find another one that truly compares. And as a woman who has tried what feels like hundreds of different brands and types of brushes Etc... this one checked every box that I need and I haven't looked back szince. Highly recommend

Meine Lieblings-Mascara seit Jahren!

Lässt sich super in mehreren Schichten auftragen und gibt einen dramatischen Look und viel Schwung.

Nice wand but mascara smudges

The wand is really nice but the mascara smudges under my eyes.

Ganz ok

Die Mascara ist gabz ok, benefit hat andere die jei meinen augen besser funktionieren.

They named it right!

Keep in mind I bought this years ago, I absolutely loved this mascara, I have barely any lashes and this mascara made them look somewhat decent which is huge for me!

It’s ok. I probably won’t but it again. It just didn’t do much for my lashes.